5-Word 365 #049 – Waiting For Superman

 Welcome to week three of Documentary Saturday.

Waiting For Superman

The inconvenient truth about education?

Well now, this is powerful stuff. Davis Guggenheim, probably best known for pointing a camera at Al Gore’s PowerPoint presentation, here points his camera at America’s broken school system, and the result is both shocking and uplifting at the same time.

First, the shocking: there are a lot of truly frightening statistics flying around this film, including my favourite, apparently 70% of eighth grade children in the States cannot read at grade level. Guggenheim pays particular attention to the issue of tenure, whereby once a teacher achieves this privilege they can effectively not be fired. As the movie says, tenure was originally meant to protect University professors from unfair dismissal on political or some other arbitrary grounds, and it had to be earned after long service and excellent performance. Now, tenure is granted to basically all teachers after two years. The interviewees depicted here all say that this is one of, if not the, main problems with public education in America. Once teachers have this protection, a lot seem to just not bother any more. If you have a guaranteed job for life what does it matter how hard you try? And it seems the teachers unions are the big problem with this. One sequence looks at an attempt by the Washington D.C. School Chancellor Michelle Rhee to change the contract with the unions to remove tenure and replace it with performance related pay that could potentially double a teacher’s salary. This prospect was so anathema to the unions that they wouldn’t even ballot their members. In the interests of disclosure, I am a member of the union in my day job. In fact, I am actually a Shop Steward. I believe very strongly in the spirit of Trade Unionism, but I do not believe that someone can stop trying to do a good job just because they can’t be fired, especially if doing so has such a massive knock-on effect. Now I have to say that this is only one side of the story. Guggenheim speaks to plenty of Superintendents (past and present) and other senior administrators, but there is no counter-argument except for a brief clip with the president of one of the two teachers unions, and it is fair to say she is not painted in the most favourable light. The main thrust of Guggenheim’s thesis is that the blame for failing standards is to be laid at the feet of the teachers that are unwilling to try and the unions who protect them from any kind of evaluation process or punitive measures for not doing their jobs.

Geoffrey Canada, president of the Harlem Children's Zone, and the ostensible star of the movie

Now for the uplifting: to give a face to these statistics, Guggenheim has spent time with five young kids from across the country; kids who want to learn and to excel and to build a good future for themselves, but who have been hampered by geography and finances and are stuck attending schools that aren’t giving them the best shot. They all get entered into the lotteries held by the private charter schools to fill their limited places. Not all of them make it, but to see how much they and their families care is a sight to behold.

Randi Weingarten, president of the teachers union. If this flick has a wicked queen, it's her.

It may be biased, it may even be manipulative, but this film certainly has an argument to make. And it is an argument that America clearly needs to get into.


  1. Bubbawheat · February 19, 2012

    Two years? Really, that’s pretty surprising. The way I understood tenure was that it was to prevent schools from firing higher paid teachers that had been around for a while and hiring fresh teachers that can be paid much less. I also know a ton of teachers from my extended family and many of my old high school friends I still keep in touch with over Facebook. Do they ever explain the odd title for the movie by the way? Surprisingly read one other review for this move a couple weeks ago but they didn’t mention it if it was in there at all.

    • Ryan McNeely · February 20, 2012

      Well the film says two years, but I haven’t checked that elsewhere. The concept doesn’t exist here in the UK though. That protection you mentioned is there for everyone under basic employment law.
      The title is explained, yeah. It’s a story Geoffrey Canada tells, where he wasn’t bothered so much by Santa but he was heartbroken when his mum told him Superman wasn’t real because it meant there was nobody coming to save him so he would have to save himself, which is why he became a teacher. The title is saying that the education system is waiting for Superman to come save it the same way little Geoffrey was.

Go ahead, punk. Make my day.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s